I want to concentrate on a unexamined aspect of this problem, one that has done much to shape what we know about the history and nature of early Christianity. In one particular historical era, anti-Christian violence did irreparable damage to our historical sources.
The story goes back to the dual origins of monasticism, which began more or less simultaneously in Egypt and Syria. From the fourth century, very large monastic settlements were beginning in both regions, and those houses became the homes of rich libraries. St. Catherine’s in Sinai is the best-known Egyptian example, while the Syriac world had one concentration of houses around Mosul, in Iraq, and another to the northwest, near the present Turkish-Syrian border. Here we find the TurAbdin plateau, the Mountain of the Servants of God. Near the cities of Nisibis and Mardin, there stood a group of perhaps a hundred monasteries that have been described as the Mount Athos of the East.
Nineteenth century scholars made dazzling finds of ancient books and manuscripts in both regions. At St. Catherine’s in 1844, ConstantinTischendorf found the fourth century Bible that we call Codex Sinaiticus. Around the same time, a Syriac monastery produced the Bazaar of Heracleides, a contemporary history of the fifth century Christological controversies written by none other than the arch-heretic Nestorius himself.
Spectacular finds were however far more common in Egypt than in the Syriac world, which is startling when we consider the massive outpouring of writing and scholarship in that culture from the fourth century onwards. One great textual find in the 1840s was the Curetonian gospels, the most ancient testimony to the Old Syriac Bible text, probably written down in the fifth century — but these came from a Syriac monastery in Egypt itself.
The more you look at the Syriac world in this era the easier it is to understand the lack of manuscript finds. Through the centuries, both Egypt and Syria/Mesopotamia were subject to various wars and raids, which had devastated particular monasteries. The earlier these occurred, though, the more likely it was that losses could be made up by copying items found in other collections. By the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, moreover, such random violence was rare in Egypt, which had an active state mechanism.
Utterly different was the position of the Syriac houses. Ottoman authority was weak in the eastern regions of the empire, which was a contested borderland between the Turkish and Persian realms. Public order was very weak, with local warlords regularly rebelling against central authority. Christian communities found themselves the targets of raids by neighboring peoples, especially the Kurds. Although these neighbors were Muslim, the attacks were usually not religiously directed. They were rather profit-seeking ventures against easy targets, like the Viking raids in medieval Europe. And in both eras, monasteries proved to be low-hanging fruit.
Whatever the causes, the old Syriac monastic world suffered dreadfully from violence. In the 1730s, this region became a battlefront during the invasion by Persian ruler Nader Shah. Nader’s forces directed their fury at the monasteries around Mosul, and slaughtered monks en masse. The monasteries subsequently rebuilt, but repeatedly through the nineteenth century, we hear of Kurdish raids inflicting terrible damage on the houses, and their libraries. Mar Mattai, one of the greatest houses, was hit numerous times in the nineteenth century, and we know of spectacular horrors like the 1828 destruction of the manuscripts at the monastery of RabbanHormizd.
In 1844, facing an armed raid, the monks of Alqosh hid five hundred precious manuscripts in a cave, but their action proved useless. Immediately afterwards, heavy rains flooded the cave and wiped out the manuscripts. Kurdish raiders, meanwhile, destroyed any documents left in the monastery itself.
Such atrocities were only the tip of a very large iceberg. When intrepid European and American travelers in these years visited the declining monasteries of the upper Tigris, they commented how often Kurds and other Muslim tribes raided the premises, taking papers and parchments that they might use for loading rifles or starting fires. These campaigns culminated in the genocidal warfare that the Ottomans commanded against Syriac Christians in 1915, when irregular forces and Kurdish militias devastated surviving monasteries and great libraries like Kudshanis.
The loss of ancient documents in these years was immense, and catastrophic. In 1840, one American traveler reported seeing at Mardin a full fifty dust-covered volumes that had apparently never been opened; ten years later, another Westerner to the same site found only a few individual manuscripts. We can only speculate what these collections might have contained at their height, and what was in those fifty lost volumes.
Given their ties to the most ancient churches, though, the Mesopotamian monasteries must have contained many ancient treasures, which are now irretrievably lost. Just what burned or flooded in the 1830s and 1840s? Which now-lost gospels? Which alternative scriptures? Which Gnostic tracts? What records of now-forgotten apostolic leaders and early Fathers?
What records from the first and second centuries survived in lone copies into the 1840s, and then perished?
What ancient histories were irretrievably lost in these years?
___________________________________
Philip Jenkins is a Distinguished Professor of History at Baylor University.
http://www.aleteia.org/en/world/article/when-they-set-fire-to-our-monasteries-5900986480590848?utm_campaign=NL_en&;utm_source=daily_newsletter&utm_medium=mail&utm_content=NL_en-24/07/2014